Saturday, August 21, 2010

A Voice for Everyone

"There are many languages besides those that are written or spoken. By learning a new language, a person acquires a new way of knowing reality and passing that knowledge on to others. Each language is absolutely irreplaceable. All languages complement each other in achieving the widest, most complete knowledge of what is real" (Boal. 1985, p. 121).

Diaries open the inner self to the same inner self. They speak, yet are silent with words only heard by the author. Entries are reflections safe from feedback. Vulnerability only occurs when trespassers violate the privacy and expose without permission. When this happens, it is an abuse, and like a rape the result is shame, fear, guilt and accusation. Diaries are life stories locked and hidden within unshared secrets.

Words that are written to fit an educational objective are locked in a predetermined product that cannot escape an assessment of one. The product is static with an identity shaped by standards of sameness,

Blogs are diaries freed of locks allowing the inner self an escape, still founded in “self-reflection, releasing pent-up feelings, and witnessing personal growth” (S. Stern, 2008, p. 101). Identity is defined by the author and the label ‘adolescence’ “negotiate[s] the boundaries of public and private spheres” (S. Stern. p. 97). Self-expression becomes the backbone of social networking and the possibilities to empower are embedded in personal site symbolism that can become a part of “the public culture” (Stern. p.97).

Are the risks worth the rewards? Are blogs, as Stern suggests, “therapeutic” (p. 102)? A former student of mine has given me permission to use her blog as an example of the powerful, insightful, and symbolic possibilities.

Part Two

You now know the story. My current students, many who are Anna's friends, know her story,and can follow her story. They are reading. They are writing. They are discussing, debating, grappling. I have to wonder how powerful this would be if allowed into the curriculum.

“Self-reflection is, perhaps, the most commonly cited reward of maintaining a personal site among youth authors” (S. Stern. P. 102). Stern speaks of a self-induced obligation blog authors have that drives reflective updates, discussion to feedback, and creative additions. The Internet author works with multiple literacies that redefine Aristotle’s peripatetic. She is a storyteller, travelling through cyber-space from computer to computer. Though the creation is for the self, it is meant to be read by a vast audience that further empowers self-expression through the reflection of self. The authors are their own directors as well as their own primary audience (p. 105).

Erving Goffman (1959) saw “all self-presentation as performative” (p. 106). The blog author becomes a performer, controlling how the self is represented and directing how words impress. The author creates a role, performs through writing, and presents a self-directed, personally designed, product (pp. 106-107). The “everyday self,” is revealed as the “authentic self,” and the performer searches for “validation” that “relieves [his] fear about being different or abnormal” (p.108).

The blog becomes transformative, as the author is in control of her identity, no longer dependent on false masks of protection. Online authors reveal a self-perception of truth and identity that can be revised as deemed necessary. Unlike a diary, a blog is alive. Blogs are learning experiences for the author as introspection is genuine, expressed through a “youth cultural production” that reveal perceptions of an authentic self.

A teacher's perception of a student's potential can also transform as a new sophistication of reality embraces words, and literacy becomes owned by the individual, not defined by an institution. Critique, too, is allowed a new found freedom, and can be answered, as desired, by the youth author.

A blog is, a new cultural experience and produces a discourse of literacy that, because it is important to youth, needs to be acknowledged by educators.


  1. Jill I enjoyed reading your post especially this sentence "The blog becomes transformative, as the author is in control of her identity, no longer dependent on false masks of protection." I wonder if you think social media sites will take over and blogs will become past tense? I looked at your students blog (which was interesting) and wonder how long she will keep it up and if she uses facebook or myspace as well. I also wonder why cant you use this as part of your curriculum, and does it need to be. I know administrators are always pushing their agendas but could you not have discussions about the blog or come up with a writing assignment using blogs? With technology every changing I wonder how long it will be before blogs are considered old.

  2. Michael,

    I grew up on vinyl as a kid, 8 track and cassette as an adolescent, cds, Ipods and beyond as an adult and have come to realize that the moment is precious, and the future is imagination.

    I know that blogs have gone from introspective to productive as authors promote ideas, agendas, and products. As far as educational use, I am grappling with the restrictions of teacher label when it comes to defining boundaries that should not confine or inhibit blog postings. I could never integrate a diary into curriculum because of many of the same reasons.

  3. I wonder if someone has done a comparison study whether students writing skills and creative communication skills are enhanced or weakened through excessive online activity?

    The difference I see in you, Jill, is that technology did not have an addictive control over your well=being. You had a balanced childhood.

  4. Jill,

    “The tongue has the power of life and death, and those who love it will eat its fruit.”(Proverbs 18:21). I can almost read your heart as you champion the right of every individual to have a voice. I am a product of that principle – my parents were denied a voice during segregation; and because of the voice of a unified people – Civil Rights Activists – I am free to express my voice now. My concern is simply this: Does your voice convey the power of life or death? What fruit are you producing in your life as a result of the voice you are publishing – life or death? Can others partake of your fruit? Or does it (fruit – voice) have the power to kill or destroy? In hindsight, should Hitler’s voice have been silenced? He didn’t use blogging or the Internet to express his version of “freedom of expression;” However, his message was received by the masses. What was the cost in human lives?

    Online authorship is a relevant, necessary tool for young people. But we must help them to champion voices that bring life and change in positive directions that benefit not just themselves, but others. We are too casual about the power of voice via the internet. Creativity without personal responsibility is dangerous. I’d like to see balance. As 21st century thinkers we should be able to come up with viable solutions that support creativity and what’s right and wrong/appropriate and inappropriate.